I asked my neighbors if they remember it being built, and one told me she couldn't believe how badly it had held up. Looking at it, I had assumed it was put in place shortly after the house was built and had settled with the land. My neighbor said it was built less than a year before we moved in! If anything, the steps have to go and be built in a way that is level and safe. I pulled up the patio pavers right up to the steps just to see what we were dealing with. Those paver steps are parked right on top of....DIRT! ha! No attempt was even made at any kind of foundation. It figures.
Not to worry, we have called in the help of an expert, so tomorrow our construction foreman, my dad, Tom, will arrive to help consider the options and attempt to make repairs. If you are bored this weekend, and are thinking that it would be super fun to lift up, move, fix, and replace multiple tons of pavers, gravel, sand, and concrete, come on over!